
Double review
My recent re-absorption back into the local Dundee hardcore scene, through the help of a few excellent shows last year, has got me reminiscing about my early gigging history and of all the long-gone bands I have seen. Back in the days when It felt like there was another hardcore show to go to every weekend at the Westie, the Balcony, and other such places. Such vibrant times and memories flooding in only helped to spark up my passion that was always an undercurrent to my metal ways that I just had to put words to screen. But how?
Conveniently through my regular appearances at a few Rad Apples shows and connection with JCHC (Jute City Hardcore) I picked up these 2 CDs which were instrumental in re-igniting more remembrances. As you can probably tell this series of compilations showcases the best, past and present hardcore bands, centered in my hometown of Dundee. Starting off the most obvious places with Part one of the series.

Taking the form of an extended split release, with all bands making a return on the 2nd half of the disc. This one may have way fewer bands than CD 2, but it makes up for this by digging up long-forgotten bands from my past as it covers the early-2000s. Let the journey begin.
Kicking off in high gear is melodic hardcore 2-step merchants Engage acting as Dundee’s answer to Comeback Kid but with a more positive outlook and bouncier riffs. Always competent and energetic this rowdy group knew how to project sweet vibes. Getting gnarlier next is a band. I sadly had no memory of Atomgevitter whose aggressively snotty nose aesthetic seems a fitting start to this comp.
Likewise the next 2 bands; I Stand Alone and The Process also escape my memory too, despite the super speedy frenzied former’s attitude standing firm against the depressive low chugs and metallic tones of the latter, but it’s Tearjerk and Filthpact that I am really sorry for missing out experiencing live. Tearjerk takes the formula of Engage above but doubles the menace, emotion, and old-school speed. Filthpact’s grindcore/power violence edge is the right blend of hardcore and extreme d-beat fuzz-toned “work ethic” that butchers and batters the right nerves.
Finally, in this 12-way split, we reach an act I have concrete memories of. Starting off with the chaotically mathy screamo of Allergo from Perth, who were frequent flyers on the stages in Dundee. Every time they played they brought their A-game, blasting out maddening tight and consistent sets of brutal hardcore, mixed with spacious interludes and mathcore madness that erupted the space they occupied.
Next is hardcore heavyweights By My Hands bringing the first beatdown to CD with their unity-defining jam “Forever Fighting”. Accompanied by the hype/entrance “intro” that made no one doubt where they are coming from as the gang-shouts of “GHC” make way for posse in full-effect hardcore stomp and two-step baiting barrages. Another classic band of the Scotland scene that always brought the masses to the pit to dance and mosh!
The side gig of prominent scene fixtures and figures, The Fight Back once again takes us back to the glorious melodic hardcore sound with more addictive riffs and heartfelt shouts, and pained grunts. Vitally strong yet mostly forgotten by me. One band that I have the strongest remembrance of is “Dundee elite” metalcore giants: A Written Apology. I think this band I saw the most times “back in the day” and have the most vivid memories of hardcore dancing too. As their keenly written and memorable tunes kept many coming back for more. Its tunes like “Catharsis Chlorophyll Consume” with its ominous Donnie Darko sound clip exploding into violent metalcore with intense riffing and manic screaming that makes destructive scenes and pits.
Sadly I think I was born too late for Twenty Centuries of Sleep as their post-hardcore and original-era screamo was way before my time in the scene though beautifully presented here. The same goes for equally obscure Condition 21 with its extremely lo-fi noisy tracks on the disc making for the least pleasant sounds so far. Thankfully it’s short and the tracks loop around again to the first band’s track 2 and onwards.
Overall this disc shows off the best side of Scotland muchly maligned and ignored hardcore scene as it was in the early-2000s which was as vibrant as it was noisy and as chaotic as it was unified in its purpose and community. These might have been the best days and nights of my life seeing these acts live, if only I paid more attention to these bands. Who knows what other gems I must have missed while being stuck in my own head or overcome with petty scene politics. I thank this CD for helping recapture some of these lost vibes in great times. [8/10]

Enough of this nostalgia! Let’s get down to business with the new and current breed of hardcore with Part II. With its strangely alphabetical approach, this monster, full-packed comp is so jammed full of exciting bands bringing fresh flavors, it is impossible for me to cover every act, so here I will just stick to the strongest acts and cuts.
The extremely fast Afterburn from the capital kicks off this compilation by providing a hazardous yet mosh-friendly banger that is over in flash. This leads on to the more metallic At Their Mercy whose violent kick is a much lengthier and thrashier affair with mosh-core breaks and beat(down)s. But all this still feels like pre-game until the real start of the disc with the next band. Bed of Wasp‘s blackened tones is an instant highlight in the CD as they combine mathcore complexity to the serrated edge of black metal from the north through gritted and broken teeth. Fantastic!
Invernesses Below The Neck‘s pleasing and monstrous track raises the heavier scale to its highest mark so far with the first truly menacing tastes of heavy-hardcore, through this metallic moshcore anthem they produce. Although it’s Aberdeen’s Bitterwood who provides the heaviest and most brutal cut on the album as its monstrous downtempo beatdown-centric deathcore takes over in an obnoxiously dense track. Beginning with an equally objectionable Simpsons sample that does take the listener by surprise, just like the extreme heaviness but this set of ruffian’s track does expand the formula slightly with a trap metal-style verse to end with. Uniquely Brutal.
Next, the mysterious Bleaks brings a classic hardcore sound in another rapid attack before centering on a Mineral-style post-hardcore mid-section. A welcome break before launching into the next onslaught. Glasgow’s Demonstration of Power is up next. DOP here carrying the torch of GHC from By My Hands clutches and barring the load with pride and excellence with a stunning piece of heavy-hardcore. A pit starting, mosh for die number that takes no prisoners. GHC colleagues in Despize quickly followed on their heels with an equally as heavy yet less memorable track.
It’s up to the Glaswegian Divide crew to finally inject a pitch melody into the proceeding with their tastefully presented melodic hardcore sound that envies Comeback kid‘s style with their own menacing grace and keen melodic hooks. But any taste of melody is quickly washed away by Endless Swarm‘s chaotic power violence approach, which possibly out-classes everyone in terms of sheer sonic roughness. Their extreme sound is best described here, though undeniably a high point of the disc.
The confrontational political Fit To Work takes a slight step back away from all the hardcore with a more classic punk-rooted vocal attack while staying top speed and furious. Freedom Fist seems to openly challenge Endless Swarm with their own extreme power violence assault that rips and gnaws with much gnashing and slams. The wailing then continues with the extremely brief yet visceral Gay Panic Defence queercore-violence takes another lunging stab at the ears, see here for more.
Get It Together’s super catchy and shouty chorus returns the melodic vibes of Divide but with ten-fold the addictiveness and foolproof charm. Providing one of the strongest tunes on the disc purely through their spirit and willful smarts in song construction. With the disc covering many hardcore and adjacent sounds and styles, it was only a matter of time before the crossover and thrashcore appears, and Hard Stare (featuring members of thrasher groups Disposable, Kingpin, & Fatal Collision) provides an excellent and concrete vital example of the sound done right and righteously furious.
Skipping through the strange bearly-listenable noisecore Headcleaner, and the predictable moshcore of Hellbound we get to old-school emo veterans Kaddish. The only act that would fit in with the first CD as well as they have existed since then. Providing copious post-hardcore vibes and first-wave screamo to captivated rooms. The example here maintains their opulent prominence. Kakihara also taking strives toward crafting their own legacy with a unique sound that portrays a deathly Converge hybrid that fills many with so much joy (just like here). Next, the brutes in Kingpin give us a quick lesson in pit starting while Glasgows Nothin’ But Enemies goes for the doctorate in slam dancing with honors.
The frighteningly dire and depressive lo-fi deathcore of Shelf takes this prize for the oddest and most unsettling listen of the bunch while Slept On‘s stomping beatdown fest is one of the most single-minded and epic pit-folly takes. The painfully low-quality production of Start Again’s quick tune is one the hardest to listen to in the wrong way. Truth Ruiner caps off this collection with another strong banger from this tape, that safely combines the average sound of all of the bands above into a safe mix of melodic hardcore and metalcore. A strong finisher.
It is safe to say that this disc is quite the odyssey in sound with many twists and turns. But overall this duo of discs feels almost definitive, and could almost be called “Now this is what call Scottish Hardcore” but that would be super-lame and undignified. As this set of bands represented here deserves much more! The hardcore scene in Scotland may not be the most prestigious compared to other parts of the world but what it lacks in recognition the bands and artists here make up for in passion, ethics, and uncompromising authenticity in sound. This is Scotland and I love it. [8/10]























